I've seen this nut cracked a dozen different ways. Each one of us has a different market environment and a different problem to solve. I am not sure that there is one answer to this issue. And don't loose sight of the fact that this is not like selling cars. Sales "programs" work great for selling new cars -- selling service is about price and credibility - relationships - long term trust and good treatment (advisor professionalism).
I know a rural dealer (30 miles to the nearest competition)that gets a healthy 30% markup on tires and sells the dickens ($64/hr) out of steering, suspension, and brakes to boot. I also know a city dealer (tire store and dealership on every corner) that virtually gives tires away at cost just to get at that repair business ($85/hr). But in each case, the market is dictating what can be done.
This is a classic market driven problem that requires managers to earn their title "manager." We all have to run the numbers on the competition, the customer reaction to our pricing, the secondary sales created, and fold in the effect of factory programs and incentives in order to craft a sales policy that will generate the best revenue stream and yet be sustainable. Having said all that, the most favorable market does not excuse unprofessionalism in service advisors - and professional, discisciplined advisors will turn an unfavorable market into GOLD.
So --- after all the market analysis and sales strategies are developed (sales programs), good advisors will make almost anything work, bad advisors will cost you money. Customers buy from advisors they trust (relationship)and price is less an issue. That is the bottom line.
Spend time developing a professional, disciplined sales team and any reasonable sales program will work.
John
pika68@aol.com